Symbianize





Traditions and Beliefs Discussions about local culture, ethnicity, superstition, urban myth, custom, or anything related to traditions and beliefs.

Reply
  #161  
Old 4th Aug 2012 Sat, 15:50
Xhirako's Avatar
Xhirako Male Xhirako is offline
The Legend
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Sa iyong guni-guni...
Posts: 5,729
Reputation: Xhirako is on a distinguished road
Total Awards: 1
Symbianizers' Choice Award in Writing  

» view all
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

...no, i'm not implying at you, you just merely say that He is ungraspable(?) to an extent and nothing else. I'm talking about some preachers and religious leaders in the pulpit making themselves the "mouth" of God to everyone.



Reply With Quote
Other Resources
  #162  
Old 4th Aug 2012 Sat, 16:24
maxgreen099's Avatar
maxgreen099 Male maxgreen099 is offline
Inactive
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Max Green House!
Posts: 933
Reputation: maxgreen099 is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

Quote:
Originally Posted by Xhirako View Post
...no, i'm not implying at you, you just merely say that He is ungraspable(?) to an extent and nothing else. I'm talking about some preachers and religious leaders in the pulpit making themselves the "mouth" of God to everyone.
haha i got your point


Reply With Quote
  #163  
Old 4th Aug 2012 Sat, 16:59
maxgreen099's Avatar
maxgreen099 Male maxgreen099 is offline
Inactive
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Max Green House!
Posts: 933
Reputation: maxgreen099 is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God


*Only fully-registered users can see this link.*


Reply With Quote
  #164  
Old 5th Aug 2012 Sun, 12:32
dhanzboy's Avatar
dhanzboy Male dhanzboy is offline
The Grand Master
 
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: UAE
Posts: 3,753
Reputation: dhanzboy is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

nagbasa ako ng balita kanina at may commentaryo na naman tungkol sa rally na ginanap sa edsa about RH bill.

Quote:
Sino tayong tao lamang ang magmamarunong at magdedesisyon kung sino ang isisilang at hindi?

Sino tayong tao lamang na nagpapakatalinong paniwalaan na ang pagdami ng tao sa mundong iba?baw ay sanhi ng kagutuman at kahirapan?


Nasusulat sa Bibliya, bago pa lang tayo maging tao, may plano na ang Diyos sa atin.


Gaano kakapal ang mukha natin para pigilan ang dakilang plano ng Maylikha? Walang nagbibigay ng kapangyarihan sa ating mga naunang nabuhay sa mundong ibabaw na monopolyahin ang biyaya ng langit at ‘wag bigyan ng pagkakataon ang mga susunod na henerasyon na maramdaman at matikman din ito.

*Only fully-registered users can see this link.*



so sinabi dito na hindi pa tayo buhay ay may plano na ang diyos sa atin. tawag dito ay god's will diba? so kung from the start ay may plano na pala ang diyos sa isang tao, malinaw na wala tayong free will dahil ang plano ay predetermined na ng diyos at wala na tayong magagawa pa para makapagdecide para sa sarili natin.


Reply With Quote
  #165  
Old 5th Aug 2012 Sun, 17:04
sivre009's Avatar
sivre009 Male sivre009 is offline
Forum Advisor
 
Join Date: Aug 2011
Posts: 629
Reputation: sivre009 is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

hahaha, pero mas maganda sana kung,
masosolve mo yung equation at d makokontento
sa alam mong sagutin ehe,

anyways, dun sa sinabi mo na, god
views time as one, edi its impossibe
for him to change the future kasi
he views all time in present.
ang future nmangyayari plng sa atin,
ay ngyari na para sa kanya. XD


Reply With Quote
  #166  
Old 5th Aug 2012 Sun, 18:29
maxgreen099's Avatar
maxgreen099 Male maxgreen099 is offline
Inactive
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Max Green House!
Posts: 933
Reputation: maxgreen099 is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

Quote:
Originally Posted by dhanzboy View Post
nagbasa ako ng balita kanina at may commentaryo na naman tungkol sa rally na ginanap sa edsa about RH bill.



*Only fully-registered users can see this link.*



so sinabi dito na hindi pa tayo buhay ay may plano na ang diyos sa atin. tawag dito ay god's will diba? so kung from the start ay may plano na pala ang diyos sa isang tao, malinaw na wala tayong free will dahil ang plano ay predetermined na ng diyos at wala na tayong magagawa pa para makapagdecide para sa sarili natin.
oo nga dude masarap sana talaga kung may freewill ang tao...


Reply With Quote
  #167  
Old 5th Aug 2012 Sun, 18:49
Xhirako's Avatar
Xhirako Male Xhirako is offline
The Legend
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Sa iyong guni-guni...
Posts: 5,729
Reputation: Xhirako is on a distinguished road
Total Awards: 1
Symbianizers' Choice Award in Writing  

» view all
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

Quote:
Nasusulat sa Bibliya, bago pa lang
tayo maging tao, may plano na ang
Diyos sa atin. Gaano kakapal ang mukha natin para
pigilan ang dakilang plano ng
Maylikha?
...sometimes, i can't help but notice the contradictions on "some" of the "divine plan" believers. If they believe God already has a divine plan before even humanity, then why bother praying so that odss will change? To ask God to modify his plans here or there just for a single human is not humility. To believe that he will modify His long laid plan just for a single tiny human is arrogance.



Reply With Quote
  #168  
Old 6th Aug 2012 Mon, 14:51
maxgreen099's Avatar
maxgreen099 Male maxgreen099 is offline
Inactive
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Max Green House!
Posts: 933
Reputation: maxgreen099 is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

its really hard to understand if freewill really exist or not! IMHO


Reply With Quote
  #169  
Old 19th Aug 2012 Sun, 12:12
maxgreen099's Avatar
maxgreen099 Male maxgreen099 is offline
Inactive
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Max Green House!
Posts: 933
Reputation: maxgreen099 is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

Quote:
Originally Posted by themanwithanironrod View Post
yup i've been there before. even the holy bible i thought all of them were really god's word whispered to the authors
but longer i studied them the more questions arise
whispered? baka marinig ni devil?

may tanong ako do you think god can change his mind?



Last edited by maxgreen099; 19th Aug 2012 Sun at 12:13..
Reply With Quote
  #170  
Old 19th Aug 2012 Sun, 12:30
spirojet's Avatar
spirojet Female spirojet is offline
Inactive
 
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: davao
Posts: 358
Reputation: spirojet is an unknown quantity at this point
Default Re: Free will vs all knowing God

Quote:
Originally Posted by sivre009 View Post
I disagree with this, the part where you say it will be done for you
that's where the other attribute of God Omnipotent comes in.

If I will kill someone, he has already foreseen that with my own freewill that I will kill someone.

Being Omniscience doesn't remove your free-will.
He just knows what your action will be.


But if an Omniscience God foreseen that you will kill someone,
then prevent/aid it in all means(Omnipotent) at that point, then there you could say you have no free-will.
I believe this so..



Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools

Forum Jump


All times are GMT +8. The time now is 06:26.